As A Fellow Stephen A., Stephen A. Smith Has Ruined My Name

The sports commentator has traded his defense of Black cultural identity for a seat at Trump's table, and I'm stuck sharing a name with a man who seems desperate for white America's approval.

As A Fellow Stephen A., Stephen A. Smith Has Ruined My Name
Stephen A. Smith Speaks At The White House After Interviewing Donald Trump
Source: Kevin Dietsch / Getty

My name is Stephen A. Crockett Jr., and I hate Stephen A. Smith.

I hate his hairline. His opinions. His fake tough-guy routine. I hate the way he spews the lyrics of white nationalism. I hate that he’s the Black Stephen Miller. But most importantly, I hate that we are both journalists and share the same first name and middle initial.

For a long time, I wasn’t embarrassed by it. In fact, there was a time when I was proud to share a name with the much more famous Stephen A. Smith. Back when he actually stood for something. He wasn’t just known for his sports opinions; he had a way of smoothing the edges of hip hop’s brash behavior. Smith became known for his undying defense of Allen Iverson, a man who wasn’t simply one of the most polarizing basketball players of the last century but also a flamboyant Black man with braids, tattoos, baggy shorts, and absolutely no interest in making white America comfortable.

Stephen A. understood that defending Iverson wasn’t just about basketball. It was about defending a Black man’s right to exist without having to explain himself to people who had already decided he was a problem. He understood the cultural significance of hip-hop, the racial politics of respectability and the double standards applied to Black athletes. And because Stephen A. got it, it felt like someone at the table spoke the language of the barbershop. 

Really, really rich.

Somewhere between becoming ESPN’s highest-paid personality and transforming himself into a walking, talking sports debate factory, Stephen A. started losing body parts. First went his spine. Then his backbone. Then his balls. What emerged was a man who seemed increasingly interested in being accepted by the very people whose cultural sensibilities he once challenged.

Now, Stephen A. Smith has apparently decided that his next career move is to become America’s most expensive Black permission slip for white political respectability.

His recent White House adventures are a perfect illustration.

In October, Smith joined Bill Maher and Kid Rock for dinner with Donald Trump at the White House. Smith defended his attendance by explaining that he wanted to advocate for historically Black colleges and universities, particularly amid the chilling effect of the administration’s attacks on diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. He said he raised concerns about corporate philanthropy drying up and argued that Trump had agreed to revisit the issue.

Fine. 

But then Smith returned to the White House on Nov. 12 to interview Trump for his SiriusXM and digital political platform, Straight Shooter. And afterward, he admitted something that should probably make anybody who remembers the old Stephen A. Smith raise an eyebrow.

He said he felt presidential. He said he felt like he belonged there. He even entertained the thought that he could do the job himself. Because for some reason, Stephen A. Smith keeps floating the idea that he could be president, and it makes sense when you consider that he’s the Black Donald Trump. He’s a windbag full of loudmouthing with no actual idea how things actually work. He doesn’t understand government, and yet, he keeps turning up in white spaces to talk about government. Doesn’t that remind you of someone? He’s literally looking at a fool in White House and going, “Hell, I’m a fool, too!”   

Meanwhile, gas prices are higher than a giraffe on stilts, and food is so expensive we are telling the cashier just to put the drink in our hands. With an endless war that appears only to benefit Israel and Epstein files still chilling the White House basement, Smith is out here playing hypothetical softball with the president, asking him questions like: If Obama could run again, would you beat him?

When Smith wasn’t softly dancing across the floor, he did cosplay as an actual journalist asking Trump how much blame he took for the Blue tsunami, and the tariffs, and the broken economy. But Smith’s insistence on cozying up to an administration whose policies directly affect Black institutions and civil rights protections deserves scrutiny over smittenness.

Smith is a fixture on white news shows. In fact, when the National Association of Black Journalists gave him the “thumbs down” award, Smith took his bruised ego over to Fox News’s Sean Hannity’s show to talk about Black people business. He’s normally on these shows to position himself as a political independent who simply wants to get things done, but he always seems hell-bent on criticizing Black women and Democrats while allowing himself to be a human footstool for Republicans. 

But there is a difference between being willing to have a conversation with somebody you disagree with and becoming so enamored with access that the conversation itself becomes a credential.

And that is what bothers me about Stephen A.

He’s spent years doing his best George Jefferson impersonation, and being unapologetically Black when it comes to sports, only for him to abandon that career for this new one in which he intends to show white conservatives that they can trust him because he’s not like the rest of us.  

There is a lucrative market for that kind of Black commentary. Just ask any number of Black conservatives who have made careers out of assuring white America that its racial anxieties are perfectly reasonable and that the real problem is Black people who refuse to stop complaining.

I don’t need Stephen A. Smith to change; I just need him to understand that a lot of us see him for exactly who he is and that evolution has not only been cringey, it’s been obvious. Positions evolve. Careers change. Bank accounts get bigger. Hairlines recede.

But I would like to know when the man who once understood the importance of challenging respectability politics became so interested in being respectful to the people who benefit from them.

And selfishly, I’d like him to stop making my name look bad.

I have spent my entire professional life as a journalist. I worked my way into the business, became an opinion editor at HuffPost and developed a career writing about politics, race, culture and the people who hold power.

I don’t know that man.

I don’t share his hairline, his opinions, his bank account, or his apparent fascination with being invited into rooms where the people inside have spent decades making life more difficult for people who look like me.

Allen Iverson once gave Stephen A. Smith something worth defending.

Now I just wish we didn’t share a name.

SEE ALSO:

Malik Beasley’s Career Went From Buckets To Bankruptcy

9 Justices, Zero Accountability, And A Whole Lot Of Problems