‘Not Sustained’ Does Not Mean Allegations Were False, Sergeant Joseph Clarifies
Police Welfare Association President and Police Prosecutor Sergeant Ann Joseph has moved to clarify what a “not sustained” finding means in a police investigation, stressing that it should not be interpreted as proof that an allegation was false. Speaking on Wednesday’s NewsMaker Live, Joseph said the terminology generally indicates that investigators did not obtain sufficient […] The post ‘Not Sustained’ Does Not Mean Allegations Were False, Sergeant Joseph Clarifies appeared first on Saint Lucia Daily Post.
Police Welfare Association President and Police Prosecutor Sergeant Ann Joseph has moved to clarify what a “not sustained” finding means in a police investigation, stressing that it should not be interpreted as proof that an allegation was false.
Speaking on Wednesday’s NewsMaker Live, Joseph said the terminology generally indicates that investigators did not obtain sufficient evidence to support criminal charges.
“If there is a conclusion of an investigation [and] it is deemed that there is insufficient evidence to prefer a charge, you would say that the matter is not substantiated, and as he said, not sustained,” Joseph explained, adding: “That is all it means.”
She stressed that such a finding does not necessarily permanently close the door on a matter, noting that it “does not mean that at that point, that’s the end, never going to happen, nothing can happen.”
Joseph said people who make allegations, or members of the public dissatisfied with the handling or outcome of an investigation, can seek further accountability. However, she cautioned against drawing definitive conclusions about cases without access to the evidence investigators considered.
“It is very dangerous when persons who do not have the facts of a particular matter” attempt to assess its outcome, she said, emphasising that criminal cases ultimately turn on evidence rather than public sentiment or personal belief. “Remember, it’s not feelings that we’re taking to court, it is evidence,” Joseph said. She noted that unlike civil proceedings, criminal cases carry a high standard of proof, placing a significant evidentiary burden on investigators and prosecutors seeking to bring a matter before the courts.
Beyond the terminology surrounding investigations, Joseph acknowledged a broader challenge facing the Royal Saint Lucia Police Force: public confidence.
Recognising that “perception is reality,” she said the organisation must do more to counter the image of the Police Force as a “dark, ugly, scary monster” and improve public understanding of how its processes work.
Joseph suggested greater transparency and a review of existing procedures could form part of that effort, particularly amid perceptions that different standards may be applied depending on the individuals involved. She described as “really unfortunate” the tendency for some people to conclude that there is “one set of laws for these persons, one set of laws for that person.”
Joseph said addressing those concerns will require the Police Force to better explain its processes and strengthen transparency, while ensuring decisions in criminal matters continue to be guided by the evidence and the standard of proof required by the courts.
The post ‘Not Sustained’ Does Not Mean Allegations Were False, Sergeant Joseph Clarifies appeared first on Saint Lucia Daily Post.