Young, Black, Gifted and NEET

Black young people have the UK's highest NEET rate. The Milburn review's reset will only close the gap if it's built for why: they're locked out, not opting out.

Young, Black, Gifted and NEET

On 17 November 2026, former Health Secretary Alan Milburn published his final review of youth unemployment, From a Welfare State to a Working State: A New Settlement for the Next Generation. It responds to a crisis that now affects close to one million 16-to-24-year-olds across the UK who are not in education, employment or training (NEET).

Milburn calls for a whole-system reset and sets a goal of “NEET Zero” within a decade. The government has accepted the review’s core principles and promised a White Paper next year, with legislation to follow.

The story inside the story

But the national average hides a sharper story. Black young people had the highest NEET rate of any ethnic group in the UK in 2024: 15.2%, against 13.1% for all young people and 13.2% for White young people, according to Youth Futures Foundation’s analysis of 2024 data. The reasons they are NEET also differ from the ones the review focuses on most. If the reset is going to work for young, Black and gifted Britain, it has to be built with that difference in mind.

15.2% of Black 16-to-24-year-olds are NEET, the highest rate of any ethnic group, against 13.1% for all young people. Close to one million young people are NEET, and 84% of those surveyed want a job or training

Not opting out — locked out

Milburn rightly rejects the caricature of a generation that doesn’t want to work: 84% of NEET young people surveyed for the review want a job or training. Much of the review then focuses on economic inactivity, especially young people held back by ill health and poor mental health.

For Black young people, the engine of the crisis is different. It is unemployment: they are looking for work and not finding it. In Youth Futures Foundation’s figures, 9.1% of Black young people are unemployed and not in education or training, nearly 1.8 times the 5.2% average. Their inactivity rate, at 6.7%, is actually below the 8.4% average. White young people show the reverse pattern: one of the lowest unemployment rates (4.9%) and the highest inactivity rate (8.7%). That is a serious problem in its own right, and the review is right to tackle it. The point is that one set of fixes won’t fit both.

In plain terms, the talent is at the door. The door isn’t opening.

The hidden NEETs

Many of these young people are also invisible to the system. Youth Futures Foundation found that 61.8% of Black NEET 18-to-24-year-olds receive no benefits at all, compared with 43.0% of White NEET peers and an average of 50.2%. Only Asian young people (75.5%) are more likely to be “hidden”.

Share of NEET 18-to-24-year-olds receiving no benefits: Asian 75.5%, Black 61.8%, all NEET young people 50.2%, White 43.0%

That matters because so much of the reform runs through the benefits system and Jobcentre Plus. Any guarantee that reaches young people through their benefit claim risks missing more than three in five Black NEETs unless the new local youth services go out and find them — through schools, colleges, community organisations, churches, sports clubs and youth networks they already trust.

The numbers: race and class

Set the two halves of the NEET rate side by side and the difference is stark. Black young people have the highest unemployment rate of any ethnic group and a below-average inactivity rate — the opposite of the inactivity-led profile much of the review is built around. (Youth Futures Foundation calculates the two halves separately from the headline NEET rate, so they don’t add up to it exactly. Compare the pattern, not the sum.)

NEET 16-to-24-year-olds by reason, 2024. Unemployed: Black 9.1%, all young people 5.2%, White 4.9%. Economically inactive: White 8.7%, all young people 8.4%, Black 6.7%

Class sharpens the picture. The Social Mobility Commission finds that among young men from lower working-class backgrounds, around a quarter of Black Caribbean (25.1%) and Mixed (25.9%) young men are NEET, compared with 23.4% of White British peers (UK, 2014–2025 combined).

Class matters for everyone. But advantage doesn’t close the gap for every group. Among young men from higher professional backgrounds, 10.9% of Mixed and 10.5% of Black Caribbean young men are NEET, compared with 9.6% of White British and 7.8% of Black African young men. The samples are small and the Commission cautions that gaps like these may not be statistically significant, but the pattern matches Impetus’s finding below.

NEET rate among young men from higher professional backgrounds, 2014 to 2025: Mixed 10.9%, Black Caribbean 10.5%, White British 9.6%, Bangladeshi 8.7%, Pakistani 8.7%, White other 8.2%, Other 8.0%, Black African 7.8%, Indian 7.6%, Chinese 7.0%

Why being gifted isn’t enough

If Black young people are actively job-hunting, the question is what stops them getting hired. The pattern is consistent with barriers in the labour market rather than a lack of ambition, and both field experiments and young people’s own reports support that reading.

A young Black man in a checked shirt works at a laptop in front of screens of code in a shared office
  • Advantage doesn’t fully protect. Impetus finds that young people from Black Caribbean and Mixed White and Black Caribbean backgrounds are more likely to be NEET even when they are not economically disadvantaged.
  • Discrimination starts at the application. In a Nuffield College field experiment, researchers sent fictitious applications to nearly 3,200 real jobs, changing only the applicant’s ethnic background. Minority ethnic applicants of all ages had to send 60% more applications than White British applicants to get a positive response, and Black Britons were among the groups penalised most heavily. Once in work, over half of young people from minoritised ethnic backgrounds report discrimination, according to a 2024 Youth Futures Foundation survey. When the problem is unemployment rather than inactivity, how employers recruit matters as much as how young people search.
  • Networks open doors. Many first jobs come through who you know: a work-experience placement, a referral, a parent’s colleague. Young people without those connections rely on open, formal routes — exactly where bias can do the most damage.
  • Apprenticeships aren’t yet a level route. The review wants apprenticeships to stand alongside university. But NatCen research for Youth Futures Foundation with Black, Pakistani and Bangladeshi young people found low awareness of apprenticeships in family networks, apprentice wages too low to live on, a lack of cultural awareness among some employers, and instances of overt and systemic racism. Action for Race Equality calls start rates for Black young people exceptionally low.

Turning a reset into real equity

The government’s first steps are promising. New locally led youth services will bring employment, health, skills and wider youth support together from next year, shaped by mayors and local leaders. A new Opportunity and Support Guarantee will offer every young person a college place, training, an apprenticeship, quality work experience or a job. The review also reportedly recommends cutting employers’ National Insurance on under-25s, starting in retail and hospitality.

A universal system will only close the gap for Black young people if it is designed to. Four tests matter:

  1. Find the hidden NEETs. Local youth services should be judged on who they reach outside the benefits system, and on offering support young people choose to take up rather than a route into sanctions. That means working with Black-led and other community organisations that young people already trust.
  2. Fix the front door of hiring. Employers taking part in the guarantee, or claiming any National Insurance cut, should use fair recruitment practices such as skills-based assessment and structured interviews. They should also offer an interview to any young person who completes an approved pre-employment programme and meets the role’s minimum criteria. Programmes can target their outreach at under-represented groups, which the Equality Act allows as positive action. The hiring decision stays on merit.
  3. Make apprenticeships pay and last. Pay apprentices enough to live on, cover travel and equipment, and fund check-ins with the apprentice and their line manager through the first six months. That will matter more than headline start targets.
  4. Count by ethnicity, sex and background. The White Paper should commit to publishing guarantee outcomes by ethnicity, sex and family background, so a widening gap for any group, including White working-class young men, is spotted early.
Four tests for the Milburn reset: find the hidden NEETs, fix the front door of hiring, make apprenticeships pay and last, and count by ethnicity, sex and background

What works: from a place on a course to a job that lasts

The guarantee promises every young person a place. Whether that place leads to a job depends on how it is run. Inspiration alone won’t do it. Black people held just 1.5% of the UK’s leadership roles in 2019, according to Business in the Community, barely changed from 1.4% five years earlier. A role model on stage rarely has the power to open the door. The hiring manager does. What works is changing the process itself — who gets interviewed, who gets support and what happens after the first day. The programmes that place young people in work, and keep them there, share six practices:

  1. Build the training backwards from the job. Ask hiring employers exactly what a junior hire must do on day one, then teach those tools, workflows and workplace skills, not a broad course.
  2. Agree interviews before the course starts. Partner employers commit to interviewing graduates who meet the role’s requirements, so candidates meet a hiring manager who trusts the programme instead of being filtered out by an automated CV screen. Outreach can be targeted. Selection is on merit.
  3. Remove the reasons people drop out. A named coach helps with housing, money or mental health problems, and the programme provides a laptop and mobile data and covers travel, so nobody leaves halfway because of a crisis or a bus fare.
  4. Make the unwritten rules explicit. Workplaces run on rules nobody writes down, and young people without professional networks are the last to hear them. Too many are judged in probation on those rules rather than on their skills. Good programmes spell out how to ask for help, take feedback and work in remote collaboration tools, and coach line managers too.
  5. Use real projects, not simulations. Building a working tool or running a real campaign for a charity or local business gives a young person concrete work to talk about at interview when they have no job history.
  6. Keep supporting after the first day. A caseworker checks in with the new hire and their line manager over the first three to six months, to sort out early friction before it becomes a reason to leave.
Six practices that turn training into jobs: build training backwards from the job, agree interviews before day one, remove the reasons people drop out, make the unwritten rules explicit, use real projects, and keep supporting after the first day. Practices 4 and 5 are marked as already part of UKBT’s Peckham DAZ programme

Across the pond: the evidence that it works

These practices aren’t wishful thinking. In the US, programmes built on several of them (paid training, real work with employers and support after hiring) have been tested in randomised controlled trials, the strongest kind of evidence: young people are randomly offered a place or not, and their earnings are compared years later. Arnold Ventures’ independent Social Programs That Work review rates the strongest of them “Top Tier”. They go well beyond mentoring and talks:

  • Year Up (rated Top Tier). Six months of employer-designed training, then a six-month internship, for low-income 18-to-24-year-olds who are neither in full-time work nor full-time study, the closest US equivalent to NEET. Participants are paid a weekly stipend, $150 a week in training and $220 during the internship, so they can afford to stay. In a federal trial of more than 2,500 young people, their quarterly earnings seven years on were 28% ($1,895) higher than the control group’s, with large gains for nearly all subgroups. Each dollar of programme cost returned $2.46 to society.
  • Per Scholas (rated Near Top Tier). Free IT training shaped by local employers, with career coaching for up to two years. In MDRC’s trial it raised earnings by more than $3,700 (26%) in the second year, and they were still 14% higher in year seven. It also reduced hardship and reliance on public assistance. And on the hidden NEETs point: over 40% of participants came through referrals from friends and family, built on more than 20 years in the Bronx.
  • Career Academies (rated Top Tier). Career-themed small schools within low-income high schools, with local employers providing work placements. Young men earned 17% more a year, nearly $30,000 more over eight years. Most students in the study were Hispanic or Black.
  • P-TECH. A partnership between a high school, a college and employers that runs from the first year of high school to a free, industry-recognised associate degree within six years. In New York, where places are allocated by lottery, students were 38 percentage points more likely to have had an internship, and 13% of young men had completed a degree within seven years, against 3% of the comparison group.
US randomised trials: Year Up raised quarterly earnings by 28% seven years on; Per Scholas raised earnings by 26% in year two; Career Academies raised young men’s annual earnings by 17% over eight years; in P-TECH, 13% of young men completed a degree against 3%

What they have in common is what the guarantee needs. Young people are paid while they learn. Training is built around real vacancies. Every participant does real work with an employer. And support continues after the job starts. These are US results, from a different labour market and benefits system, and they won’t carry over one for one: Year Up selects motivated applicants who have finished school, and Per Scholas’s results come from a single site. But the lesson is consistent across all four. Paid, employer-linked routes with support after hiring raise earnings for years. Talks and mentoring alone don’t.

UKBT already does some of this: Peckham DAZ

These aren’t abstract ideas for us. Peckham Digital Accelerator Zone (Peckham DAZ) was an 18-month programme that UKBlackTech ran with the UAL Creative Computing Institute and Southwark Council, as part of the Institute of Coding’s Click Start programme funded by Nominet. It trained more than 200 young people aged 18 to 30 from Black and ethnic minority backgrounds in south London, in accessible web development and data science, free of charge. Several of the six practices were built in:

  • Real projects, not simulations. Students worked with real footfall and shop-spend data for Peckham High Street from the GLA’s High Street Data Service, and built visualisations and apps that helped local retailers through Peckham Business Forum. Others took part in the Women’s and Girls’ Health Hackathon with NHS South East London, King’s Health Partners and the King’s Institute for Artificial Intelligence. Students came away with real work to show on their CVs, GitHub profiles and personal websites.
  • The unwritten rules of work. Alongside the technical courses ran job readiness workshops, one-to-one career coaching, sessions on Scrum and agile teamwork, and personal branding.
  • The real jobs behind the training. Industry partners, from a data centre operator and a digital product consultancy to global tech companies, explained the roles they hire for, what the work involves and how to interview for it.

Graduates have gone on to roles in advertising, telecoms, banking and local government, started their own businesses, and moved into further study. (Partners named took part in programme activities. Naming them doesn’t imply they endorse this article.) The next step is the part no single programme can do alone: employers committing to interviews before a cohort starts, funding for the support that keeps young people on course, and check-ins through their first months in work. That is where the guarantee, the new local youth services and employers can build on what already works.

Employers and professionals don’t have to wait for legislation. Offering a live project, or an interview to programme graduates who meet your minimum criteria, opening up work experience, mentoring a young person, sharing your network and paying entry-level talent properly all help gifted young people get through a door that is currently closed to too many of them.

The Milburn review says young people are not the problem. For young Black Britain, the evidence agrees: they are ready, willing and looking. The reset will be judged on whether the system finally meets them halfway.

Why UKBT exists

The task now is to make sure young people’s talent is seen, developed and connected, rather than lost to barriers that have nothing to do with ability.

That is why UKBlackTech and the UKBT Institute exist. Talent gets lost when young people can’t reach the people and sectors that hire. So we bring young people into technology and the sectors it is transforming, such as life sciences and health, and connect them with professionals across the ecosystem — doctors, scientists, academics, engineers and entrepreneurs.

This isn’t new work for us. For the past decade, UKBT has actively engaged with NEET young people. We have run hackathons, mock interviews, tech events and innovation activities that give talent new ways to apply their tech skills to real-world challenges, such as women’s health. We have provided work experience placements and trained young people in AI and data science. Again and again, we have seen what happens when talent is given access, belief and a real problem to solve.

This speaks directly to the gaps the evidence reveals:

  • Reach. More than three in five Black NEET young people are outside the benefits system. Trusted community organisations already reach them, and the new local youth services will need partners like us to do the same.
  • Networks. When so many first jobs come through who you know, a professional community gives young people connections that formal routes alone cannot.
  • A route in. The ambition is already there. Seeing real careers in tech, health and life sciences, and meeting the people who hire for them, turns it into a plan.

We do this through two connected parts:

  • UKBlackTech — Community, Content, Careers & Collaboration. Our professional community and digital platform brings together people in entrepreneurship, technology and academia. We inspire, connect and develop the next generation of innovators through technology, entrepreneurship, digital skills and knowledge sharing. Members build their profile, showcase their work and grow their networks.
  • UKBT Institute — Research, Innovation, Discovery & Impact. Our research and innovation arm brings together technologists, clinicians, data scientists, engineers, academics, entrepreneurs, policymakers and grassroots communities to investigate emerging technologies and turn ideas into pilots, prototypes and real-world solutions.

We want to make sure the reset opens doors rather than adding hoops, working alongside government, mayors and employers. Whether you are NEET today or an established tech professional, there is a place for you here.

Looking for work? Join the UKBlackTech community for events, hackathons and connections to people who work and hire in tech. Hiring or working in tech? Offer one interview, one live project or one hour of mentoring.

A word from Mark Martin MBE

“The Milburn review is right that young people are not the problem. For young Black people, the evidence is clear: they are ready, willing and looking for work. What too many lack is access — to networks, to the people who make hiring decisions and to a clear view of where their talent can take them.

At UKBT, we’ve spent ten years showing what happens when those doors open. Now we want to work with government, mayors and employers to make sure this reset reaches every gifted young person, not just the ones the system already sees.”

Mark Martin MBE, UKBlackTech

Sources