Who Gets to Become a Lawyer in Australia?
3 mins read by Neo Pitso “You are better off sticking with private schools because…
3 mins read by Neo Pitso

“You are better off sticking with private schools because that’s where future lawyers actually come from.”
A teacher offered me this advice last year during a conversation about legal careers at a secondary school in Melbourne. The comment exposed a disconnect between how the legal profession presents itself and how some people experience it.
For many African-Australians aspiring to legal careers, the question is not simply whether they can study law, but whether they can see themselves reflected in the profession’s most influential spaces.
Who is Counting?
Take the Bar, which for some is the pantheon of pure advocacy. Barristers are the ones who stand up in court and argue the case in court, and the most senior among them, known as silks, are some of the most influential lawyers in the country. So how many African-Australian barristers are there?
The numbers are hard to find, and that tells its own story. The Victorian Bar’s 2023 survey found that 13 per cent of the barristers who responded were born overseas, compared with 29.3 per cent of the Australian population. I could not find a published figure for African-Australian barristers at all. That absence reflects a broader problem; it is difficult to have a meaningful conversation about African-Australian representation at the Bar when so little is known about how many African-Australians have reached it in the first place.

Australian research continues to find that socio-economic background, Indigenous status and non-English-speaking background shape educational and labour market outcomes even among university graduates. Unequal access to information, networks, career guidance and money helps explain why. Conversations about merit often focus on who succeeds, while paying less attention to how different their starting points were.
Barriers Old and New
The Law Institute of Victoria uses the term “emerging lawyers” to refer to law students, graduates and lawyers at the beginning of their careers. For African-Australians becoming a lawyer often means navigating a profession where many of the rules are unwritten. Few lawyers consciously set out to keep others on the outside, but the profession’s gatekeeping is baked into structures and norms that keep people out just as effectively. Unpaid placements, for example, can exclude students who cannot afford to forgo paid work.
Australian law began by refusing to recognise First Nations law, and African-Australian emerging lawyers are pursuing their futures on land that was taken and never ceded. Those of us who have encountered barriers of our own have a responsibility to stand with First Nations peoples in their long fight for justice, on the terms they set.
What Is the Hidden Curriculum?
The hidden curriculum refers to the assumptions, behaviours and knowledge that institutions reward without explicitly teaching, a concept developed by educational sociologist Philip Jackson in Life in Classrooms. In law school, it includes knowing how to challenge an idea in class without seeming disrespectful, how to approach a lecturer, how to recover from a poor grade and how to find opportunities beyond the classroom. Some students arrive having absorbed these rules through their networks; others encounter them for the first time after enrolment.
Merit Under Pressure
A first-in-family student might be juggling study and employment while decoding professional norms and deciding whether speaking up will be interpreted as inexperience. The pressure to appear capable can discourage the very questions that deepen understanding and sharpen judgment. As those questions go unasked, the appearance of confidence can be mistaken for competence.
In Decolonising the Mind, Kenyan writer Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o argued that language is never neutral, it decides whose knowledge counts as authoritative. Law has its own version of this. The ways of speaking and arguing it accepts as professional usually belong to those who understood its unwritten rules long before law school. Everyone else has to learn the law and, at the same time, learn how a lawyer is expected to sound.
Can a system be called meritocratic when the rules for demonstrating merit are only taught to some?
A Different Inheritance
Knowledge of how professions operate is often passed from one generation to the next. Some aspiring lawyers inherit knowledge about clerkships, chambers, the Bar readers’ course and career progression through family and professional connections. Others must discover these pathways for themselves.
For many African-Australian families, particularly those whose migration to Australia is relatively recent, professional knowledge may not have accumulated across generations as it has for families with longer histories in the law. As a result, many students are required to build from scratch what others inherit. The apparent scarcity of African-Australian barristers cannot be explained simply by individual ambition or ability.
The scarcity of African-Australian lawyers also means the scarcity of everyday conversations that help demystify the legal profession for others. When few people in a community have experience of legal education or practice, knowledge about career pathways and sources of legal help is less likely to circulate through everyday relationships.
Building relationships with lecturers, peers and practitioners can provide access to insights that others encounter through family or established professional networks. These efforts cannot dismantle structural inequalities on their own, but they can help create a different inheritance for those who follow.
Beyond Good Intentions
The teacher I spoke with that day was describing the legal profession as she understood it. Our task is not to criticise her, but to change the conditions that made her observation plausible.
The question is not whether African-Australians are capable of succeeding in law. The presence of African-Australian solicitors, barristers, academics and judicial officers already answers that question. The better question is why so few African-Australians appear in the profession’s most influential spaces, why nobody is counting, and whether opportunity, mentorship, networks and professional knowledge are reaching talented people equally.
A profession committed to justice should be as attentive to who enters it as to the standards it expects of those already inside. African-Australian professionals can help pass on the knowledge and networks they worked hard to acquire, shortening a journey that many emerging lawyers currently have to navigate from scratch.
Ultimately, the scarcity of African-Australian barristers is a reminder that professional pathways are learned as much as they are earned.
END
About the Author
Neo Pitso is an emergy lawyer and keynote speaker based in Melbourne.
