Don’t let Labour MPs sell out the green agenda
Decisions like the Rosebank oil field go beyond party politics. We need politicians to act out of conviction The post Don’t let Labour MPs sell out the green agenda appeared first on Bylines Network.

“The uncomfortable reality is that party loyalty in Labour often takes precedence over political principle”, writes Sarah Canning. She cites the example of Stroud’s MP Simon Opher, who, despite being regarded as one of the more environmentally minded Labour MPs, and being chair of the Net Zero All-Party Parliamentary Group, has supported the government’s position on drilling at the Jackdaw gas field.
When Labour came to power under Andy Burnham last summer, many people hoped it would signal a genuine shift in the direction of environmental policy. There was hope in the early days that the new leadership had been paying attention to the Green Party’s agenda, even borrowing its language of hope and promising a fairer, greener future.
But political rhetoric is one thing. What happens when those promises are tested?
Burnham’s backtracking
Despite endorsing the Fossil Fuel Treaty last year, describing it as “a call to end coal, oil and gas, hold polluters accountable”, Burnham’s government has now given the go-ahead to drilling at the Jackdaw gas field in the North Sea. His justification? That “these things have to be considered in the round”.
For a government that claims to take the climate emergency seriously, this is a deeply disappointing decision.
And what about our South West Labour MPs? My own MP, Dr Simon Opher here in Stroud, often regarded as one of the more environmentally minded Labour MPs, and chair of the Net Zero All-Party Parliamentary Group, has publicly supported the government’s position on Jackdaw.
The claims don’t stand up. In a video defending the decision, Dr Opher argued that using domestically produced gas would result in significantly lower carbon emissions than importing gas from overseas. It is an argument that sounds plausible, but it doesn’t stand up to closer scrutiny.
First, the majority of emissions associated with natural gas arise when it is ultimately burned. Whether that gas comes from the North Sea or overseas makes no difference to the carbon dioxide released when it is used. This was also central to the legal challenge against Jackdaw, where the courts found that the climate impact assessment had failed to properly account for emissions resulting from the eventual use of the gas.
Second, much of Britain’s imported gas comes from Norway, which has comparatively low emissions from gas extraction. Norwegian offshore operations benefit from measures such as electrification, using renewable energy, on the rigs. There is no guarantee that the Jackdaw platform will achieve anything comparable.
The argument that domestic extraction is automatically greener is therefore far from convincing. So why is our supposedly green MP defending it?
Party versus planet
The uncomfortable reality is that party loyalty in Labour can often take precedence over political principle. The parliamentary whipping system exists to ensure MPs generally vote in accordance with their party’s position. MPs can rebel, of course, but doing so can come at a political cost, particularly when the government considers an issue important.
Perhaps Dr Opher genuinely believes the government’s argument. But if so, he needs to explain how his support for Jackdaw sits alongside his environmental commitments and his previous support for the Fossil Fuel Treaty and similar positions on reducing carbon emissions and reaching net zero.
This is one of the fundamental differences between Labour and the Green Party. The Greens do not operate with the same traditional parliamentary whipping system. Their elected representatives are given greater freedom to exercise their judgement, with an emphasis on building consensus rather than simply following the party line.
Regardless, Dr Opher has another opportunity to demonstrate where his environmental principles really lie.
The Rosebank decision
As I write this, the government is building up to a decision on the Rosebank oil field, one of the UK’s largest undeveloped oil fields, but its oil is destined for the international market. There is little reason to believe that extracting it will significantly reduce energy bills for British households or deliver the economic benefits its supporters suggest.
What it will do is create another revenue stream for an already hugely profitable fossil fuel industry. With Shell reporting billions in profits, it is difficult to argue that the oil and gas companies are in desperate need of government assistance.
Dr Opher has previously expressed opposition to Rosebank and, on 10 November, wrote to the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero, Miatta Fahnbulleh, opposing a green light being given.
He also attended a recent debate on the topic secured by Green MP Carla Denyer.
It has been reassuring to see Dr Opher, along with a growing group of other Labour politicians, speaking out. He cited in his letter many of the key points that the Green Party, and others who oppose the opening of the field, have raised for some time. Not least that Rosebank would do nothing to bring down energy bills.
But, with the power of the fossil fuel lobby, meeting with government officials reportedly an average of twice a week for the past two years, will this Labour government bow to the pressure being placed upon them? The test will come for Dr Opher if the government chooses to put the interests of the fossil fuel industry ahead of the climate. It will be interesting to see how far Dr Opher’s principles will propel him to stand up for what is right for people and the planet.
Do what’s right, not what’s expedient
As a Stroud resident, I want my MP to make the difficult decisions when it matters most. That means supporting an economy that works for ordinary people, investing in genuinely sustainable industries and holding the government to account when it gets things wrong.
Being an MP should mean more than representing the position of your party. It should mean representing the people who elected you, even when that means having difficult conversations with your own leadership. Dr Opher may well need to stand up and strongly oppose his party’s position, particularly if the decision to green-light Rosebank is given, and show that his environmental credentials amount to more than good intentions and carefully chosen words. This could be the greatest test of his party vs principles to date.
For those of us who want a genuinely green future for Stroud and the country, that is a question worth watching very closely.
Sarah Canning is a Green councillor representing Amberley & Woodchester on Stroud District Council.
Comments? We want to hear them. Please write to editor@westenglandbylines.co.uk
The post Don’t let Labour MPs sell out the green agenda appeared first on Bylines Network.