Lord Rennard is exonerated – but was another complaint process warranted?
An attempt to re-open an investigation into allegations against Lord Rennard, investigated and dismissed in 2013, has been dismissed The post Lord Rennard is exonerated – but was another complaint process warranted? appeared first on Bylines Network.

Lord Rennard faced accusations of sexual harassment at a critical time for the Liberal Democrats in 2013. An investigation by the Metropolitan Police decided not to send any file to the Crown Prosecution Service. An independent investigation by Alistair Webster KC subsequently concluded, after reviewing all the evidence, that there was insufficient evidence to justify a disciplinary hearing. This “No Further Action” decision was accepted by the Liberal Democrats and upheld on appeal by a panel whose conclusions were deemed to be “final and binding on all the parties” in the party’s constitution. A second investigation by Law Professor Christine Willmore also determined that there was no basis for any disciplinary hearing on any basis against Lord Rennard and this was again accepted by the party. A review of the party processes by independent businesswoman Helena Morrissey concluded in December 2014 that “there was no justification for any ambivalence towards Lord Rennard’s position in the party”.
Then in Feb 2026 a new complaint was made, seeking to re-open the allegations dismissed in 2013/14 and claiming that the investigation by Alistair Webster KC more than twelve years earlier may have been flawed. This month, it was announced that the new complaint had been firmly rejected by an independent panel advised by Elliott Gold KC.
The Complaints Panel dismissed the new complaint against Lord Rennard, ruling that it lacked jurisdiction under the recently approved September 2025 party procedures because transitional rules had mandated that complaints reported before July 2019 remained governed by previous procedures. The 2013 “No Further Action” decision was found to be contractually final and binding on all the parties. Furthermore, it ruled that later disagreement with Alistair Webster KC’s evaluation constituted an “evaluative disagreement” rather than a fundamental procedural defect. It said that reopening allegations after 12 years would create an oppressive abuse of process violating principles of natural justice.
Lord Rennard released an official statement after the latest decision. He also emphasised that neither Ed Davey, nor Lord Dixon (who brought the new complaint), nor anyone associated with them ever had access to the substantial body of evidence which had led to the dismissal of the original complaints in 2013/14.
The legal advice which the new complaint was supposed to be based upon could not be produced for either Lord Rennard, his colleagues in the Lords, or for the Complaints Panel to examine it. This leaves open the question as to how and why a new complaint against him could have been made without properly providing this legal advice and which came from an anonymous source without any indication as to what materials had been provided to examine?

The post Lord Rennard is exonerated – but was another complaint process warranted? appeared first on Bylines Network.